An easy mistake would be to offer some general thoughts on the source, perhaps doing all of the above, but not to really answer this question.
Is it in the first or third person? Cite this Article A tool to create a citation to reference this article Cite this Article. I like to think of this as: Does the author talk about apples frequently? An increased consideration of material culture in recent years has made this more true than ever.
Use personal adjectives that express how you felt while reading this book and how you feel after reading. If you are an avid reader, then it will be fairly easy to write this form of review. What imagery is used?
However, whether a source analysis or a review assignmentthere are some similarities with the usual essay. Remember, the question is not: Is it descriptive, analytical or ironic, etc?
More than naming it, this means identifying the type of source it is.
Give your overall opinion of the work. Basically, what is the book about? What do we need to know about the broader picture to make sense of this source? Yet students often complain of exactly that. Consider the limitations of the source.
Identify and summarise the source. However, I would advise against using the term bias. Remember, there is no one form for a primary source. Likewise, quantitative or visual sources need to be handled appropriately.
Saying so can often mask the need to ask how. You can find book commentaries in magazines and online. Better to identify the perspective from which events are described.
How does this source compare to others? The closing sentence needs to wrap up the discussion by giving a clear answer to the question. It would be unrealistic to expect one source to provide the answer to every question.
How useful is this source to historians? There are particular challenges and opportunities offered by private or official writings, even when the author is the same.
How does the characterization work?Writing a book commentary is similar to writing a book review. Commentaries tend to be more direct and express the commentator’s views regarding the book. You can find book commentaries in magazines and online. Do's and Don'ts for Writing Commentary by Adria Bader (printable version here)This checklist was originally developed for Writing Consultants, but it works well in any course that involves written peer critique of papers.
Step 1: Read the text!! • Read the text several times: – First time read quickly to get a gist of what the text is about. – Then read more slowly, looking for the main ideas.
How to Write a Good Essay Part 1: Learn the Difference between Commentary and Summary You need to understand the difference between commentary and summary. While both writing styles can be used to discuss another piece of work (like a play, book, movie, or.
Aug 15, · I think you'd also want to comment on the narrations and transitions of literary text as noticing them would give high marks in the IB and MYP programme. May 29, at PM a nice way to write a commentary would be to locate and separate the various themes in a passage; for example, in a poem, some common themes might be Author: ibstudent.
Mar 06, · Writing a Source Commentary The bread and butter of studying history is the use of primary sources. So it’s no surprise that a common assignment in a History degree is to write a source commentary or analysis.Download